■

実業家のひろゆき氏が２５日、自身のＸを更新し、死刑についての思いを明かした。この日、京都アニメーション放火殺人事件で３６人を殺害した青葉真司被告に、京都地裁は死刑判決を言い渡した。

ひろゆき氏は、被害の大きさから判決に理解を示した上で「死刑になるための人を助けた医療関係者の努力を考えると、『死刑だから助けなくていい』という判断があってもいいような、、、」と青葉被告を治療した医療関係者への思いを示した。これに医師・弁護士の資格を持つ立憲民主党の米山隆一氏が反応。Ｘで「まず判決が確定するまでは死刑になるかどうか分かりません。判決確定後も、執行までは再審もあり得ます。それ迄は、被疑者・死刑囚としての制限は受けても人権を有し、病気は治療するのが法治国家です。助けない判断はあり得ません。」と説明し「ネタの可能性を否定しませんが、グロテスクな意見だと思います。」と斬った。

Businessman Hiroyuki updated his X on March 25 and shared his thoughts on the death penalty. On that day, the Kyoto District Court handed down the death sentence to Shinji Aoba, the defendant in the Kyoto animation arson and murder case that killed 36 people.

Hiroyuki expressed his understanding of the verdict due to the extent of the damage, and expressed his feelings toward the medical personnel who treated defendant Aoba, saying, "Considering the efforts of the medical personnel who helped people to get the death penalty, it seems like there should be a judgment that 'because it's a death sentence, there is no need to help...'" He also expressed his feelings toward the medical personnel who treated Aoba. Ryuichi Yoneyama of the Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan, who is a qualified doctor and lawyer, responded to this, saying in X, "First of all, we don't know if the death penalty will be imposed until the verdict is finalized. Even after the sentence is finalized, there can be a retrial until the execution. Until then, even if he is restricted as a suspect or a prisoner on death row, he still has human rights, and the rule of law is to treat his illness. There can be no decision not to help." He explained, "I do not deny the possibility that this is a story, but I think it is a grotesque opinion. I think it is a grotesque opinion.

ひろゆき氏は「死刑囚を生かす治療をするのは『裁判をする為』とか言われますが、生き延びて証言する事で死刑が免れる証言が存在するか？というと今の裁判官の判断基準では死刑一択だな、、と。」と分析。「生かすなら状況証拠だけで死刑が決まる裁判システムを変えないと意味がないかな、、と。」とつづったが、米山氏は「これも誤りで、今回問題になった心神喪失が認められれば、今回の案件でも死刑を免れられます。また、実行行為、故意、因果関係、違法性阻却事由の不存在等の認定も必要で、状況証拠だけで死刑は決まりません。」と指摘した。

ここで高須クリニックの高須克弥院長も参戦。Ｘで「米山先生のおっしゃる通りです。満点です。」とたたえた。「医者は敵でも犯罪者でも目の前に患者がいれば全力で助けるのが使命だと存じます。医道は法律より上位にあると信じている昔かたぎのかっちゃんなう。」と医師としての思いもつづった.

Hiroyuki said, "It is said that the treatment to keep a death row inmate alive is 'for the sake of the trial,' but is there any testimony that can spare him from the death penalty by surviving and testifying? But is there any testimony that would allow him to live to testify and avoid the death penalty? He analyzed the case. If he is to live, he must change the trial system in which the death penalty is decided by circumstantial evidence alone, otherwise it will be meaningless." However, Mr. Yoneyama said, "This is also wrong. If insanity, which is the issue in this case, is found, the death penalty can be avoided in this case. In addition, the death penalty cannot be determined by circumstantial evidence alone, as it also requires a finding of the act of commission, intent, causal relationship, and the absence of grounds for the exclusion of illegality. He pointed out.

At this point, Katsuya Takasu, director of the Takasu Clinic, joined in, saying in X: "Yoneyama-sensei is right. He got a perfect score. He praised him. I believe that a doctor's mission is to do his or her best to help a patient, whether he or she is an enemy or a criminal. I am an old-fashioned katchan who believes that the way of medicine is above the law. He also wrote about his thoughts as a doctor.